"Well, he and Leafpool ran away, but they came to their senses and came back and broke up," Mothwing explains. "Perhaps it's understandable that it was awkward between them, since every cat knew about what a disaster it was. But he took a mate in his own clan, Nightcloud, and anyone could see he didn't love her. It was all for show, so he seemed like a proper clan cat. In my opinion, he should have just kept his head down and worked hard at being a good warrior and everyone would have forgotten in time. Well, except that he got Leafpool with kits, so that always would have been a problem..."